SM Entertainment has a unique strategy of releasing “track” videos – clips designed to build hype for upcoming comebacks, spotlighting album tracks that aren’t necessarily the lead single. These videos can sometimes offer a glimpse of a song, or even present the entire track. With NCT 127 gearing up for their tenth anniversary comeback, the anticipation is palpable. While fans might do a double take at the current five-member lineup, a shift from their previous ten, the focus remains squarely on the music, and their new track, “Piñata,” certainly demands attention.
A Full-Throttle Rock Dive
“Piñata” sees NCT 127 venturing full-throttle into a rock sound, complete with their trademark shouty hooks. As long-time followers know, NCT acts often shine when electric guitar is woven into their tracks. It consistently injects a widescreen, ambitious energy that perfectly complements the expansive vision of the NCT brand. However, “Piñata” presents a challenging listen from the outset.
While shouting a song’s hook can be incredibly effective, particularly within punk genres, K-Pop generally struggles to integrate it successfully. The intricate production typical of K-Pop can sometimes render these shouted centerpieces more shrill than truly thrilling. In “Piñata,” this tonal approach genuinely hurts the ears at times. A deliberately unpleasant track can resonate if it conveys a specific message or artistic intent, but here, the shouting feels somewhat gratuitous.
Unlocking Hidden Potential
Conversely, “Piñata’s” verses adopt a far more restrained approach, yet unfortunately, they fall into familiar and predictable patterns. Both the phrasing and execution feel like the song and members are merely going through the expected motions. The track’s undeniable strongest moment, however, arrives during a regrettably brief bridge. This section unleashes an explosive rap segment that the production actively calls for, hinting at a more freewheeling energy that could have been harnessed. We can only wish more of this dynamic vigor had been present throughout “Piñata,” instead of the cut-and-paste assertiveness that defines much of the track.
Hooks
6
Production
8
Longevity
7
Bias
7
RATING
7
Grade: C-
